Child Custody & International Disputes
International custody disputes can be some of the most frightening and complex challenges divorced parents face. When one parent lives abroad—or takes the children across borders without consent—the legal process quickly extends beyond California family courts. The Hague Convention offers a framework for resolving these cases, focusing on returning children to their home country and preventing international child abduction. Understanding how these protections work and what steps to take immediately can make all the difference in safeguarding your parental rights.
Child Custody & International Disputes
International custody disputes can be some of the most frightening and complex challenges divorced parents face. When one parent lives abroad—or takes the children across borders without consent—the legal process quickly extends beyond California family courts. The Hague Convention offers a framework for resolving these cases, focusing on returning children to their home country and preventing international child abduction. Understanding how these protections work and what steps to take immediately can make all the difference in safeguarding your parental rights.
When borders complicate custody, you need more than hope—you need a plan
When divorced parents live in different countries, custody disputes over their shared children become significantly more complex, potentially involving another nation’s legal system and differing views of parental rights. For many parents, that can give rise to the fear that their ex-spouse might attempt to relocate the children to a country more favorable to their custody claims, or that they would simply refuse to return them after authorized visitation abroad.
While these fears are not unjustified, parents have recourse if their ex has taken (or kept) their children out of the country without their consent. International law includes protections under the Hague Convention to deter child abduction and to establish a framework for determining the correct jurisdiction to decide custody matters, in most cases, the local courts where the child habitually lives.
What You’ll Learn In This Post:
- What Is the Hague Convention on International Child Abduction?
- How Does California Apply the Hague Convention in Custody Disputes?
- What Happens If a Parent Takes a Child Abroad Without Consent?
- How Do California Courts Work with International Authorities Under the Hague Convention?
- What Legal Remedies Exist for Parents Facing Cross-Border Custody Issues?
- Why Should Global Families Work with a California Family Law Firm Experienced in International Custody?
- Frequently Asked Questions
What Is the Hague Convention on International Child Abduction?
The Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction is an international treaty first established in 1980 to facilitate the prompt return of children under age 16 who have been wrongfully removed from their country of habitual residence or kept from returning there by a parent or guardian. As of this writing, more than 100 countries are signatories to the convention. The purpose of the Hague Convention is not to decide matters of child custody across international borders, but to return the child to the jurisdiction of their habitual residence so that custody matters can be resolved in the court system there. Both the country the child was removed from and the one they were removed to must be signatories for Hague Convention protocols to apply.
According to the Hague Convention, “wrongful removal” occurs when taking the child to another country, or keeping them there, violates the other parent’s custody rights under the law of the state where the child was habitually resident right before the removal or retention, and when that parent was exercising those rights (or would have been if the child had not been taken or kept from them). If the children have been removed from the country before a custody order has been entered, it is still possible to request their return under the Hague Convention.
How Does California Apply the Hague Convention in Custody Disputes?
If a child has been wrongfully removed from their habitual residence to another Hague Convention signatory country, the court will not rely solely on U.S. custody rules. The Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and Enforcement Act (UCCJEA) defines a child’s “home state” based on six months of residence or significant connections, and while those ideas can offer useful context, they are not controlling in Hague cases. Instead, courts look at the totality of the circumstances, considering factors such as how long the child has lived in a particular country, where they attend school, and their ties to the community.
The Hague Convention also provides for certain exceptions where the child is not required to be returned, and the court will consider if any of these apply. These include:
- The petition was filed more than one year after the wrongful removal or retention.
- The left-behind parent was not exercising their custody rights when the child was removed or retained.
- The petitioner had consented or acquiesced to the removal or retention.
- The child would be exposed to physical or psychological harm or otherwise placed in an intolerable situation if returned.
- The child objects to being returned and is old and mature enough for it to be appropriate for those views to be taken into account.
What Happens If a Parent Takes a Child Abroad Without Consent
Taking a child overseas without the consent of their co-parent can be viewed as child abduction. The parent who is left behind can file a Hague Convention petition or pursue similar legal action to have the child returned to the United States through international legal channels. In addition, the International Parent Kidnapping Crime Act (IPKCA) makes it a federal crime to remove or retain a child outside of the United States to obstruct another parent’s custodial rights. Ultimately, this type of action can negatively affect their share of child custody, as it demonstrates a disregard for the child’s best interests and may violate existing custody orders, even if no criminal charges are brought against them.
How Do California Courts Work with International Authorities Under the Hague Convention?
California courts’ involvement in Hague Convention cases depends on whether they are incoming cases, when a child has been brought to or kept in California from another country, or outgoing cases, where they have been taken from the state to a foreign country or retained there after they should have returned. In incoming cases, the court will decide if the removal or retention was wrongful and whether the child must be returned under the terms of the treaty; if a Hague exception applies, they may rule the child should remain in the state.
For outgoing cases, California courts are generally not involved beyond issuing custody orders or supporting documents related to the petition. The U.S. Central Authority (the State Department) and local district attorneys, who are charged with carrying out the state’s responsibilities under the Hague Convention, assist left-behind parents in pursuing their case abroad. This can include helping prepare Hague Convention applications, monitoring the progress of the case in the foreign jurisdiction, and collecting and providing additional supporting documentation and information, as necessary.
What Legal Remedies Exist for Parents Facing Cross-Border Custody Issues?
Although the Hague Convention offers a framework for returning a child who was taken from their home without consent, its limitations highlight the value of a proactive approach to prevent such removals in the first place. An international custody agreement should include terms requiring mutual consent for travel or relocation to minimize the risk of abduction. Typically, both parents’ consent is required to obtain a U.S. passport for a child under age 16; if the child does not already have one, a parent who suspects their co-parent might try to get one without their knowledge can enroll their child in the Children’s Passport Issuance Alert Program to be notified if an application for their child is submitted.
If the risk of abduction is high, a parent can obtain a court order preventing travel, which can allow them to enroll their child in the U.S. Customs and Border Protection’s Prevent Abduction Program. The assistance of a skilled attorney can be key to creating effective agreements and for building a compelling case for additional protections when necessary.
Why Should Global Families Work with a California Family Law Firm Experienced in International Custody?
When families are separated by international borders, the path to finding a custody solution that preserves parental relationships and prioritizes a child’s best interest is much more complicated. These situations involve jurisdictional issues, knowledge of the legal systems in different countries, and expertise in applicable international treaties such as the Hague Convention, making it vital to work with a family law firm experienced in international child custody cases. Their understanding of cross-cultural issues, potential pitfalls, and effective legal strategies can help chart a more efficient path to a fair resolution.
At Hoover Krepelka, the largest firm dedicated solely to family law in Northern California, our attorneys have the legal expertise you need to successfully navigate complicated international custody issues. To schedule your consultation, fill out the form below today.
Reach Out To Our Expert Attorneys Today
FAQS
How does California apply the Hague Convention in international custody cases?
California courts use the Hague Convention to determine whether a child should be returned to their home country, focusing on preventing wrongful international removals rather than deciding long-term custody.
What happens if one parent takes a child abroad without consent?
If a parent takes a child abroad without the other parent’s permission, it may be considered international child abduction, and the left-behind parent can seek the child’s return through the Hague Convention.
Can California courts enforce custody orders across national borders?
Yes. California courts can work with foreign courts and central authorities under the Hague Convention to recognize, enforce, or facilitate compliance with custody and return orders internationally.